The agency was never told what to deliver.
Most of the time the contractor isn’t underperforming. They were never told what performing meant.
- Read what they were actually asked to do
- Read what came back
- Put the two side by side
Evidence
of a national brand’s followers sat on two pages where almost nobody reacted
Samsung Ukrainekinds of buyer one website had to speak to, for a veterinary biotech startup
Filka Lifethe scope cut on a drone project, which is why it sold
UAV Commercialisation ProgrammeMost of the time the contractor isn’t underperforming. They were never told what performing meant.
Not views or likes: one number that changes the business, agreed by both sides.
Checked monthly by somebody who isn’t doing the work and isn’t paid by its volume. That is the whole job.
For an agreed period I take that seat: the priorities, the tasks and the numbers.
How it runs
You end up able to tell a good contractor from a badly managed one, and to prove which you have — with somebody senior holding it there while your team gets used to it.
Replacing a contractor who is doing fine and being managed badly.
A title without access to the decisions.
A pair of senior hands to execute what has already been decided.
Monthly once it runs itself. Weekly, and inside the business, while it doesn’t.
Priced per engagement, agreed before anything starts.
40% of small businesses that outsource their marketing leave the agency, and 56% of those leave within six to twelve months. The most common reason given was not seeing a return — 60% said the return was inadequate.
What the survey establishes is that not seeing a return is the common reason these relationships end. It does not say whether the cause was the work, the measurement or the supervision. What it does show is that replacing a contractor cannot fix an accountability system nobody ever defined.
Source: inTandem / vcita, 2025 SMB Marketing Report. 500 US small-business owners, surveyed April 2025, published July 2025. A software vendor’s survey of its own target market, not an audited market estimate. Read the source
With a free first call of about an hour. Bring what is happening and any numbers you trust; if this isn’t the right domain, I’ll tell you on that call.
Send the agency’s last report and what you pay them. I’ll tell you what I’d check first.